• Walt Disney World
    • WDW News
    • WDW Festivals & Events
    • WDW Foodie
    • WDW Resorts
    • WDW Dining
    • Magic Kingdom
    • Epcot
    • Hollywood Studios
    • Animal Kingdom
    • Disney Springs
    • WDW Transportation
    • Fairytale Weddings
  • Disney Cruise Line
    • DCL News
    • Disney Wish
    • Disney Dream
    • Disney Fantasy
    • Disney Wonder
    • Disney Magic
    • Onboard Activities & Entertainment
    • Castaway Cay
    • Port Adventures
  • Disneyland
    • Disneyland News
    • Disneyland Festivals & Events
    • Disneyland Foodie
    • Disney California Adventure Park
    • Disneyland Resorts
    • Disneyland Dining
    • Downtown Disney
  • Universal Studios
    • Universal News & Updates
    • Universal Studios Florida
    • Islands of Adventure
    • Volcano Bay
    • Universal Studios Hollywood
    • Universal Resorts
    • Universal Dining
    • Universal Entertainment & Events
    • Universal Foodie
  • Disney Destinations
    • Adventures by Disney
    • Aulani Resort
    • Disneyland Paris
    • Tokyo DisneySea
    • Tokyo Disneyland
    • Shanghai Disneyland
  • About Us
    • Meet Our Team
    • Preferred Partners
    • Get In Touch
    • Privacy Policy
  • Book Your Vacation

Explore

  • Walt Disney World
  • Disney Cruise Line
  • Disneyland
  • Universal Studios

Connect

The Kingdom Insider

Orlando and Family Travel News Lifestyle and Information

Disney's Hollywood Studios, WDW Dining, WDW News · May 17, 2020

Peanut Butter and Jelly Milkshake Recipe from 50’s Prime Time Cafe

For as long as I can remember, one of my favorite treats in all of Walt Disney World has been the Peanut Butter and Jelly Milkshake at 50’s Prime Time Café at Disney’s Hollywood Studios. It is the perfect blend of sweet and rich! I always strategically get it after I check all my thrill ride fast passes off my list so I can truly enjoy it.

50's Prime Time Cafe in Disney's Hollywood Studios
50’s Prime Time Cafe in Disney’s Hollywood Studios offers nostalgia flavors in a cooky ambiance! Photo: Disney

Fun Fact: This recipe was created in 1989 when a group of chefs were carrying out a menu tasting for 50’s Prime Time Café restaurant. Since its creation, it’s become a mainstay in the park and popular fan favorite! In fact, the restaurant sold more than 27,000 of these in 2016! It’s a recipe I have loved making at home as well.

Peanut Butter and Jelly Milkshakes at 50's Prime Time Cafe in Disney's Hollywood Studios
50’s Prime Time Cafe’s Peanut Butter and Jelly Milkshake has been offered since the opening day of Disney’s Hollywood Studios. Photo: Disney

See how they make it in the park in the video below!

Since the original recipe calls for ice cream, jelly, milk and peanut butter, a lighter, more “everyday” snack version has been on my list to find! Disney Parks came out with a DIY Peanut Butter n’ Jelly shake featuring whole strawberries in place of jelly. Check out that video below!

The switch from jelly to whole strawberries made the beverage a little easier on the stomach from the reduction in added sugar, but the ice cream still made it more of a dessert. Now, I am quite a big Disney Dessert fan, that is for sure! However, as many of you might guess, as a Dietitian, I like fitting in more whole Disney snacks that I can eat any time and not JUST for dessert! Enter: my Disney Parks -Inspired Peanut Butter n’ Jelly Smoothie recipe!

Peanut Butter and Jelly Milkshake
My Peanut Butter and Jelly Smoothie will satisfy your craving for the iconic shake from Disney Parks!
Ingredients for Peanut Butter and Jelly Smoothie
Simple ingredients are used in the smoothie and allergy-friendly alternatives can easily be swapped in!

Here, I swap out the vanilla ice cream for vanilla Greek yogurt, adding more protein, and bonus – probiotics for gut health and immune support (1, 2, 3)! The whole strawberries that replace jelly are an excellent source of vitamin C, an antioxidant necessary for immune and skin health, offering even more benefit to this magical beverage (4, 5)! That’s right, with my Peanut Butter n’ Jelly Smoothie, you actually get some health benefits from drinking it daily (should you wish to do so).

DIY Disney Inspired Peanut Butter and Jelly Milkshake Smoothie

Disney Parks Inspired Peanut Butter n’ Jelly Smoothie

Ingredients

2 cups frozen strawberries, slightly thawed
¾ cup 1% milk or (dairy-alternative of choice – plain or vanilla flavored)
1.5 cups low-fat vanilla Greek yogurt (or non-dairy vanilla yogurt of choice)
2 Tbsp Peanut Butter

Directions

  1. Place all ingredients into a blender adding the peanut butter last.
  2. Blend until smooth and fully mixed.
  3. Garnish with a fresh or frozen strawberry and serve immediately. Enjoy

Note: If you’re looking for the iconic jelly flavor, swap out the strawberries for 2 tbsp grape jelly, or try 2 tbsp raisins for a more whole food approach.

The nostalgia will hit you every time you drink this delicious smoothie. If you’re interested in more Disney Snacktivities, check out the following links and don’t forget to Comment below and on our Facebook page about your DIY Disney Snack Creations at home!

Pluto Snack and Activity Time
DIY Dole Whip
Green Smoothie of Te Fiti
Churro Popcorn
Dietitian’s Favorite Disney Family Recipes

Posted By: TKI Newsroom · In: Disney's Hollywood Studios, WDW Dining, WDW News

According to Disney- This is What You’re Voluntarily Agreeing to When You Visit Disney Springs Beginning on May 20th
Take a Trip to Walt Disney World with This Disney+ Watch List!

You’ll Also Love

Stan Lee’s Legacy Honored at Avengers Campus in Disney California Adventure Park
An Insider Sneak Peek Into Star Wars: Galactic Starcruiser Adventure
Magic Kingdom: New Fun Treats to Try!

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Even More Magic

  • Shop Disney
  • Find A Travel Agent
  • Pack Your Park Bag With TKI

Pack Your Bags, It’s Time to Set Sail!

Follow @thekingdominsider on Instagram!

The Disney100 celebration at Disneyland officially The Disney100 celebration at Disneyland officially starts today!✨We hope you’ve enjoyed following along in our stories, where we were able to give you special peek into what’s in store for everyone during this special celebration. Between the merch, food and treats 🧁, characters in special costumes, shows 🎆…there’s just so much fun to be had! We will have even more to share with you guys over the next few weeks, so stay tuned! 

✨You can also tap into our Disney100 highlight reel to see all the preview content if you didn’t get a chance to follow along in real time! 
•
•
•
•
•
#disneyland #disneycaliforniaadventure #dca #mickeymouse #goofy #disneyparks #hostedbydisney #disneyclassic #waltdisney #disney #disneystorytelling #disneymagic #disneygram #annualpassholder #disneycreators #disneyinstagram #disneyparks #disneymagic #magickey #sharethewonder #disney100
Hey…yes, you! 👋🏽 Are you following along i Hey…yes, you! 👋🏽 Are you following along in our stories? Kristin is covering the preview of the Disney100 celebration at Disneyland 🏰 and Disney California Adventure, and you won’t want to miss a thing! 

Disney100 commemorates the storytellers who have brought generations the wonder and magic of Disney and how these beloved characters and stories connect us. All are invited to share their favorite Disney, Pixar, Marvel, Star Wars, 20th Century, and National Geographic memories✨

•
•
•
•
•
#disneyland #disneycaliforniaadventure #dca #goofy #disneyparks #hostedbydisney #disneyclassic #waltdisney #disney #disneystorytelling #disneymagic #disneygram #annualpassholder #disneycreators #disneyinstagram #disneyparks #disneymagic #magickey #sharethewonder #disney100
We can’t wait for a Rootin’ Tootin’ time at We can’t wait for a Rootin’ Tootin’ time at the all-new Roundup Rodeo BBQ coming March 23rd to Disney’s Hollywood Studios!🐴✨ Buckle up cowboys & girls, because we’ve got a full run down of all the yummy food coming to town over on thekingdominsider.com 🤠 Y’all check it out now, ya hear! 

•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
• #toystoryland #toystory #hollywoodstudios #woodysroundup #disneyfood #disneytreats #disneyfoodie #disneysnacks #disneyhungry #disneyworld #waltdisneyworld #disneyparks #disneyfamily #disneykid #disneykids #disneynews #disneyshollywoodstudios #buzzlightyear #disneyworldcommunity
Foodies rejoice, as yet another Epcot festival is Foodies rejoice, as yet another Epcot festival is here to snack around the world!✨🧇🍦🍉 Taste test this artful treat at The Festival of the Arts now through February 20th!🎨✨ (hold down the foodie info slide & screenshot for ALL the details on these plated dishes!)😋 #artfulepcot 
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
• #artfulepcot #epcot #epcotfestivalofthearts #epcotfood #epcotcenter #epcotworldshowcase #thomaskinkade #disneyartwork #disneyart #waltdisneyworld #waltdisneyworldresort #disneyworld #disneyfood #disneyhungry #disneyfoodie #disneycreators #disneygram #disneyinsta #disneyparks #disneyphotography #epcoteats #disneyartfans #disneyfood#figment #disney100 #disneycommunity
Have you ever seen The Nighttime Lights at Hogwart Have you ever seen The Nighttime Lights at Hogwarts Castle?✨🏰 Every night, after dusk, muggles & wizards alike can catch the beautiful light show accompanied by the iconic music multiple times throughout the evening! (About every 20 minutes✨) It’s not to be missed on your next trip to the Islands of Adventure theme park!🪄Can’t wait? Watch the show NOW on our YouTube channel!🎥
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
• #butterbeer #harrypotter #wizardingworldofharrypotter #wizardingworld #diagonalley #hogsmeade #theleakycauldron #threebroomsticks #thelostbros #happychristmasharry #themepark #universalstudios #islandsofadventure #uni #univ #tistheseason #buttersstotch #harrypotterfan #harrypotterforever #hogwarts #orlandoflorida #wizard #muggle #muggleborn #youreawizardharry #orlandothemeparks #ioa #butterbeercheers
Bienvenidos to Disney’s Coronado Springs Resort! Bienvenidos to Disney’s Coronado Springs Resort!👋🏻 Take a tour of our spacious, double queen room in the beautiful Gran Destino Tower!✨ I mean, just look at that view!😍 
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•

#disneyresort #disneyresorts #disneyresorttour #disneyonabudget #disneykids #disneyrestaurant #disneyroom #disneyreel #disneyreels #disneyadult #disneyadults #disneyfamily #waltdisneyworld #waltdisneyworld50 #trendingreels #waltdisneyworld50thanniversary #waltdisneyworldresort #disneyfood #disneyparks #disneytips #hoteltour #roomtour #disneyannualpassholder #disneyfamily #magickingdom #hollywoodstudios #epcot #coronadosprings #coronadospringsresort
The Walt Disney Company marks its 100th anniversa The Walt Disney Company marks its 100th anniversary this year, and beginning Jan. 27, the Disneyland Resort will commemorate the milestone with new experiences, entertainment and more throughout 2023!✨ Are you headed to Disneyland this year?! There’s SO much NEW to see & do, and now… we’re officially less than a week away from the start! 🥳🎶🏰 Between new sparkly merchandise, and the return of the Magic Happens Parade, we can hardly contain our excitement!!😬 
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
• #disneystyle #disneyhome #disneymerch #disneymerchandise #disneycreator #disneycreators #disneymagic #disneytech #waltdisneyworld #disneyears #getyourearson #mickeyears #minnieears #mickeymouse #disneyoutfit #disneydecor #disneykid #disney100 #disneymerchalert #disneyfamily #disneyland #californiaadventure
Wishing you a MALEFICENT weekend, Insiders✨ You Wishing you a MALEFICENT weekend, Insiders✨  You can catch the Festival of Fantasy parade daily at 12:00pm & again at 3:00pm! Make sure you grab a good viewing spot ahead of time! My favorite is at the end of Main Street with a castle backdrop!📸🏰

•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
• #disneyworld #festivaloffantasyparade #waltdisneyworld #waltdisneyworldresort #waltdisneyworldresorts #disney50thanniversary #magickingdom #magickingdompark #hollywoodstudios #epcot #disneyparks #disneykid #disneygram #disneyears #mickeymouse #disneygram #disneyfamily #disneyparade #disneyphotography #disneycreators #disneycommunity #maleficent #styledbymagic
  • Get In Touch
  • About Us
  • Shop Disney

Copyright © 2023 The Kingdom Insider · Theme by 17th Avenue